Retirement Plan Rescue Story #1 : Keeping an "Overfunded" Pension Plan from Being Terminated

August 18, 2026

The Challenge 


A business owner came to us after receiving confusing news from their retirement plan actuary. 


Their Defined Benefit (Cash Balance) Plan had performed exceptionally well over several years; strong investment returns seemed to have created what’s called an overfunded Plan. While it seems like a positive name, an overfunded plan can create excessive and unexpected tax liabilities. 


So, their actuary recommended terminating the Plan by transferring the excess assets into the company's other Plan, a 401(k)/Profit Sharing Plan, before eventually closing both Plans, a lengthy and complicated process. 

The Hidden Risk 


The recommendation seemed straightforward. But something just didn't feel right to our team. While it would solve the immediate overfunding issue, it would also create several new problems. 


First, once participants reached their maximum allowable benefit levels, excess assets could revert back to the employer and be subject to heavy taxes. In similar situations, employers often lose the overwhelming majority of excess assets to taxes. 


Second, while the original Cash Balance Plan primarily benefited key executives and owners, the intention was for the replacement plan to cover the entire employee population. That meant that excess assets transferred into the replacement Plan had to be allocated according to that Plan's rules—not simply redirected to the executives. 


The recommendation solved one problem while potentially creating two much larger ones. 


The Rescue 


So, instead of simply asking, "How do we get rid of the excess assets?" we asked a different question: 


"What happens if we keep the assets?" 


Our team projected the Plan several years into the future, instead of focusing solely on its current position. 


Their analysis revealed something important. 


Defined Benefit Plans are generally designed around predictable, long-term returns—not years of exceptional market performance like this Plan had achieved. So, if the employer adjusted the investment strategy toward more stable, conservative returns and simply allowed the Plan to continue operating, something else would naturally occur over time. 


Namely, IRS benefit limits would continually increase with annual cost-of-living adjustments, gradually “absorbing” much of the excess funding over the coming years. 


In other words, with good proactive planning, the problem could naturally resolve itself. 


The Outcome 


So, rather than terminating the Plan, the employer was able to choose a much simpler path: retain the existing plan, adjust the plan’s investment strategy to better align with actuarial assumptions, and allow future benefit increases to naturally reduce the surplus over time, thus avoiding unnecessary taxes or having to reallocate any assets. 


The Lesson 


Most importantly, they avoided making a permanent decision based on a temporary situation. 


Sometimes the best solution isn't taking immediate action—it's understanding how today's decisions will affect the next five or ten years. 


Retirement plans should never be managed by looking only in the “rearview mirror”, i.e., what happened last year. Good retirement plan management also isn't just about calculating numbers correctly. It's knowing that patience is often a key part of the strategy. 


November 5, 2026
Real estate can be an attractive investment. But owning real estate inside a qualified retirement plan can introduce a very different set of rules… and sometimes some very unusual problems. Years ago, one of our clients came to us with an opportunity he didn't want to pass up. He had been offered the chance to purchase a spectacular home overlooking a well-known California golf course. There was one major problem: Most of the money he had available to purchase the home was tied up inside his retirement plan. So, he asked us a question: Could his retirement plan buy the property? Technically, yes, it could. But that didn't necessarily mean it was a good idea.
October 9, 2026
As we wrap up the third quarter of 2026, one theme continues to emerge: effective retirement plan administration requires more than simply keeping up with regulatory changes. It requires proactive oversight, an understanding of each employer's unique circumstances, and the ability to identify potential problems before they become costly mistakes. This quarter, we took a closer look at the retirement plan challenges facing law firms, nonprofit organizations, and home healthcare providers, exploring how compensation structures, workforce dynamics, and plan design can create unexpected compliance risks. We also examined important technical considerations, including after-tax contributions, nondiscrimination testing, and the limitations of increasingly automated retirement plan platforms. We continued our Retirement Plan Rescue Stories series, sharing real-world examples of how overlooked administrative responsibilities, inadequate oversight, and seemingly minor operational errors can lead to significant consequences for employers. These stories reinforce an important point: the true cost of retirement plan administration isn't always reflected in the fees employers pay.  Below is a recap of the articles we published this quarter. We hope they provide practical insights to help you navigate evolving requirements, recognize potential risks, and make more informed decisions about your retirement plan.
September 28, 2026
Sometimes retirement plan problems begin with bad decisions. Other times, they begin with good intentions.
More Posts